What makes a dish iconic and timeless?

Eggs Benedict

Eggs Benedict for brekkie at the Waldorf Astoria New York

What makes a dish iconic and timeless? Is it all about simplicity and soul food? We live in an era where molecular gastronomy and sous vide cooking techniques govern many a hotel and restaurant kitchen, yet chefs are also going back-to-basics pairing down their dishes, or so they keep on telling us.

Think Caesar salad, a beef burger, club sandwich, French onion soup, prawn cocktail and crepes suzette. Or up the ante slightly with Waldorf salad, eggs Benedict and red velvet cake – either first invented or popularised at the Waldorf Astoria New York in the 1930s. Well this particular hotel chain has decided to find the next #TasteofWaldorf dish, in the hope that it too will stand the test of time.

Hotels outside the Middle East struggle to drive food and beverage revenue from the restaurants they operate, given stiff competition from excellent independent restaurants. Why would you want to eat in a sterile hotel restaurant in New York or London when you’re spoilt for choice with creative standalone concepts elsewhere? The dynamic is very different here given licensing laws and the vast choice of restaurants in every hotel. It’s always good to see chains becoming more inventive with their F&B marketing.

Making red velvet cup cakes

Making red velvet cup cakes in the Waldorf Astoria New York kitchen

Five emerging American chefs (James Beard semi-finalists – a US foundation that celebrates the country’s culinary heritage) were dispatched to five Waldorf Astoria properties around the world for a week to apprentice with a master chef to create the next iconic dish – the first time these chefs had ever worked together. And last week, the five-paired chefs met in New York to prepare their dishes for a judging panel at an invitation-only dinner, one I was lucky enough to attend, and to cast my vote. The winning dish (more on that later) will be rolled out on menus at 26 Waldorf Astoria hotels around the world including Dubai, Ras Al Khaimah and Jeddah next month.

So who were the chefs and what did they serve? Some sound bites from my interviews:

Chefs Pierre Gagnaire and Chris Kajioka

Pierre Gagnaire and Chris Kajioka's pumpkin and foie gras veloute


Pierre Gagnaire helms 11 restaurants around the world including Reflets par Pierre Gagnaire (at the Intercontinental Dubai) and Les Solistes at the Waldorf Astoria Berlin. What’s even more incredible than his empire, is his recent award for Best chef in the world’ voted for by over 500 of his peers (chefs from around the globe whose restaurants boast two and three Michelin stars), bumping French legend Paul Bocuse to the number two spot. Chris Kajioka has worked at Per Se in New York and Vintage Cave in Hawaii as executive chef. He opens a new restaurant this year in Hawaii.

  • Their dish? A pumpkin and foie gras veloute with brioche of Comte cheese and beetroot.

“We already had a pumpkin foie gras soup in our restaurants and we wanted to refine that by giving it a more international twist. Foie gras is very Frenchy. And pumpkin is a fairly iconic and humble American ingredient, so we elevated it using French cooking techniques. We added green curry and squid for a Far Eastern flavour. Soup is becoming very popular so that was also something we wanted to capitalise on.”

Taste of Waldorf chefsTaste of Waldorf dinner

Chefs Heinz Beck and David Posey

  • Heinz Beck who us Dubai folks know from lending his name to Social at the Waldorf Astoria Palm, is the head chef at Rome Cavalieri’s La Pergola, a three Michelin star restaurant. He opens a new casual Italian café at the Galleria mall in Dubai towards the end of April, with more planned across the UAE. David Posey has left his chef de cuisine role at Blackbird in Chicago to open his own restaurant this year.
  • Their dish? A new take on the Waldorf salad – a celery root ‘risotto’ with apple, hazelnut and black truffle.

“We took the flavours of a Waldorf salad and turned it into a risotto by making a stock out of risotto rice [Heinz came up with a great technique David had never seen before] and diced celery to look like rice. A very creamy, healthier version of a Waldorf salad. We used the same components of apple and hazelnut, but topped it with shaved black truffle. It’s an easy dish to replicate with only five ingredients. And you don’t have to use the truffle.”

Heinz Beck & David Posey's celery risottoJeff Galvin's venison scotch egg

Chefs Jeff Galvin and Cara Stadler

  • The Galvin brothers and classicists, Jeff and Chris, head up the Waldorf Astoria Edinburgh’s dining programme with The Pompadour by Galvin and Galvin Brasserie De Luxe – just two amongst their UK stable. Jeff spilled the beans that they are about to sign their first two restaurants in Dubai – at Citywalk – opening in October. Cara Stadler, recognised by Food & Wine magazine as one of America’s best new chefs, is the owner and head chef at the Asian fusion restaurant Tao Yuan and Bao Bao Dumpling House in Maine (she was in the midst of opening another restaurant and understandably unable to attend).
  • Their dish? A simple venison scotch egg.

“Eggs Benedict was the first thing I cooked at catering school over 30 years ago so to go full circle is amazing. We began our careers in hotels. You have just arrived after a long flight, it’s late and you want comfort food either as room service or in Peacock Alley [the Waldorf Astoria’s renowned all-day café-cum-bar]. We each came up with a huge list of ingredients and then met to discuss. Shortlisting ingredients was a challenge, but we went deer stalking and decided on venison as the main ingredient. We’ve also used Scottish heather honey and a celeriac remoulade.”

Chefs Jimmy Schmidt and Eduardo Ruiz

  • An innovative pioneer in America’s culinary movement towards sustainable cooking and farm-to-table dining, La Quinta Resort’s chef Jimmy Schmidt is a three-times James Beard Award winner and one of the original members of its foundation. Eduardo Ruiz was named one of Zagat’s 30 Under 30, and is the executive chef and owner of Picnik restaurant and Corazon Y Miel in California.
  • Their dish? Earth and sea, i.e. surf and turf. But what are the ingredients and how is it made?

“We encapsulated the great ingredients from the Americas, all from nearby farms – chilli, corn, shrimp and great beef (Wagyu from Indiana). We used new cooking techniques, like sous viding the meat, whilst focusing on health and maximising nutritional intake. Allepo-infused salts for curing the beef, to finishing salts for garnishing – there isn’t one ingredient that isn’t used more than two times. We made a Wagyu golden culinary oil from the fat that has 91% omegas and blended it with the corn juice and solids for a mock corn nut butter – much bigger flavours than a dairy butter. The butter is then incorporated into the polenta, the base of the dish. The sauces are all made with toasted walnut oils. The shrimp is marinated with a little bit of the salt and walnut oil. Big flavours and great nutrition go hand in hand.”

Jimmy Schmidt and Eduardo Ruiz's earth and seaJan van Dyk and Marjorie Meek-Bradley's suckling pig

And the last dish by chefs Jan van Dyk and Marjorie Meek-Bradley

  • Jan van Dyk is the executive chef at the Waldorf Astoria Shanghai on the Bund, offering modern French cuisine infused with classics. Marjorie Meek-Bradley also worked for Thomas Keller at Per Se and now oversees the kitchens at Ripple and Roofers Union in Washington DC.
  • Their dish? A rack of suckling pig with Xiao long bao (a soup dumpling) and wolfberry scallop.

“We explored the town and tried different dumplings along with the different regional Chinese cuisines. We wanted to bring Shanghai to a Western plate. We barbequed the pig to give it its crispy skin (similar to Peking duck).”

As you can see, all five dishes were hugely different in cooking style, ingredients and inspiration. All were packed with flavour bar one in my opinion – the suckling pig. I was also astonished to see pork on the menu, given this ingredient could never be served in Waldorf Astoria’s Qasr Al Sharq property in Saudi Arabia – and would struggle to become a timeless dish in the UAE with such a huge Arab customer base. If you look at my Instagram feed, I pretty much ate nothing but pork in New York, but my custom isn’t enough. Admittedly when I questioned Jan van Dyk (who incidentally has worked extensively in Oman), he was quick to reassure that the swine could be substituted with duck or lamb. Fair enough, but perhaps more consideration should have been given to the key ingredient.

What dish did I vote for? Jeff Galvin and Cara Stadler’s venison scotch egg – the only dish in my opinion that ticked the comfort food box; the only one I would crave after a long flight; and the only one that would work easily on a room service menu. All key factors in making a dish timeless.

But that’s not the dish that won…the drum roll is reserved for Heinz Beck and David Posey’s celery ‘risotto’ – with Heinz literally jumping for joy hugging each chef, Pierre Gagnaire first. An endearing sight. He had never entered a competition before, let alone won – astounding revelation for a chef of his calibre.

Chef Heinz Beck cheeringHeinz Beck and David Posey

You will be able to taste the dish at Waldorf Astoria hotels around the world as of next month. A special overnight #TasteofWaldorf package will also be bookable. Or if you prefer here’s the recipe to make it yourself (click on ‘recipes’ and then the photo of the dish). There’s a wonderful video of the two chefs’ collaboration here. I was on Dubai Eye’s Travel Show yesterday chatting through this event – click here for the podcast (scroll to LitFest 2015 3 and 4 – 3rd March).

Time will tell if the new celery ‘risotto’ becomes iconic. In the meantime, what’s your timeless go-to dish? Does a celery ‘risotto’ appeal?

Stay tuned for a post on food and restaurant trends from these chefs.

A bientôt.

FooDiva. x

Disclosure – I was flown to New York by Waldorf Astoria to report on this event. I may have been plied with food and wine, but the opinions expressed here are, as always, mine alone.

  • Posted under
    Chefs, Dishes, Food Features, Foodie Happenings, Hotels, Licensed, New York, Restaurants, UAE
  • Pin It

11 Responses to “What makes a dish iconic and timeless?”

  1. JayEim March 4, 2015 at 12:20 pm

    O Sole Mio

    I thought the video clip of the lady trying to get into her tight jeans was pretty hilarious.

    Not that I would know what is the relation of Eggs Benedict with Scottish Eggs beside the eggs or Jeans sizes to that matter.

    But the whole event looks like……well kind of forced!

    Famous dishes were not borne out of competitions but from a sheer passion for food or plain luck…….and sometimes for the love of a woman 😉

    Please do enlighten me as to which Famous dishes were born out of a food contest to complete my knowledge…..and I just found out that the Waldorf Salad was not even created by a Chef but the Maitre D’ of the time….Oh well, it’s all in the family.

    So now we have a Risotto made out of Celery cooked in Risotto rice, hang on a second, why call it Risotto if does not contain Rice…..might as well rice cut the apples – celery – nuts and whatever and make a porridge, add snails and Heston Blueindaface is your uncle!

    So the Risotto is cooked with either veg stock or veal stock and then we have again veal demi glace (made with or without tomatoes) as there are many ways to do a veal demi glace which the recipe does not bother to explain and…..

    Is this post going anywhere?

    Let me summarize:

    I don’t think I will order such concoction unless I am charged a mortgage premium, a nice shot of Pisco Sour would help as well and then I will instaTweetFacePin to the world at large wiz my brand new Louboutin shoes with the red soles and my car underside painted in red for color harmony……..
    Come to think of it, all restaurants floors should be reflective so people can admire the Loobotomy red otherwise there is no reason to wear Loobotomy shoes or eat Celery rice if you cannot broadcast it to the world.

    P.S. I have celery salt in my pantry which I use for my Chicago Dogs, now I will sprinkle on my rice with a diced apple and nuts…..Sorted!

    P.P.S. I am working on a Virgin Pisco Sour but cannot get passed the egg whites 😉

    P.P.P.S. I am thinking of a Tabbouleh Risotto or Horiatiki Risotto. Any takers?

    • FooDiva March 4, 2015 at 4:11 pm

      I am cracking up AGAIN Jay. Good job my sense of humour matches yours 🙂

      I hear what you are saying to an extent, but you can’t take away the fact that this idea from the WA team is a pretty good one. Competition between hotels and restaurants is fierce nowadays in contrast to the 1930s, so we can’t compare like for like, or apples for apples 😉 Hotels really struggle to drive footfall from in-house guests, residents and tourists/business travellers, so credit to them for thinking out of the box. I should add that I know a little because I worked for Hilton in the MEA corporate office for six years 😉 It was interesting being on the other side of the fence with this trip.

      As for the dish itself, one listener to my radio spot yesterday made the dish for herself last night without a recipe – see here. https://instagram.com/p/zy867Hn_oo/?modal=true
      That’s a swift and powerful call to action in my opinion.

      You’re right about Oscar, the maitre d’ fronted the operation and even produced a cookbook. I should have mentioned that in the post. I did share that on social media when I was there. I would welcome your thoughts of course 🙂 https://www.facebook.com/foodivaworld/photos/pb.147959668584392.-2207520000.1425470260./801453066568379/?type=3&theater

      Keep those comments flowing Jay, they make my day, and my readers’ am sure 🙂

  2. Garry W March 5, 2015 at 10:31 am

    The venison scotch egg sounded very nice – the Caledonian is known for its creativity. Hopefully the Waldorfs in the GCC will have the celery risotto on their menus pronto.

    • FooDiva March 7, 2015 at 5:19 pm

      I could easily eat the venison scotch egg every day…gutted it didn’t make the cut Garry.

  3. GA March 5, 2015 at 5:07 pm

    Jetsetter 🙂 I would have picked the venison Scotch egg too 🙂

    • FooDiva March 7, 2015 at 5:22 pm

      Well I am a #TravelDiva too lol GA. Looks like the scotch egg would have won the public over!

  4. IshitaUnblogged March 6, 2015 at 9:11 am

    What an interesting read… and a great experience for you as well. A timeless dish should be less complicated and shouldn’t contain celery (please! or kale!). The vension scotch egg sounded too good.

    • FooDiva March 7, 2015 at 5:23 pm

      Incredible three days Ishita. Talking of kale, everyone was eating kale salad in NY. I even spotted a Caesar kale variation…really in sub-zero temperatures?! Bring on those carbs pretty please!

Trackbacks and Pingbacks

  1. Top chefs share food and restaurant trends - FooDiva | FooDiva - March 9, 2015

    […] musings of international celeb chefs and their emerging peers as shared with me in New York for the #TasteofWaldorf […]

  2. Meet chef Oliver Glowig - Bahrain restaurants - FooDiva | FooDiva - March 29, 2015

    […] aside, I left Munich for Italy where I met my wife who is from Capri [his good German chef friend Heinz Beck also married an Italian – from Sicily]. When I went to my mother-in-law’s house, I loved her […]

  3. A soft shell crab dish you must eat - Crab Tavern - Dubai restaurants | FooDiva - August 24, 2015

    […] gem lettuce, and a smattering of fresh anchovies with croutons. A good, classic Caesar salad is a timeless dish anyway, but this twist of delightful soft shell crab (and runny egg) makes it pure soul food – a […]

I’d love to receive your feedback, so feel free to comment any time.